Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig Engaged: Their Story

It's official: Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig are engaged. Shue, the "Melrose Place" star, told People he proposed this past spring. The news is surprising partly because of how the two came to know each other. Their former spouses, Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes, were at the center of one of TV's biggest workplace scandals. Here is what we know about the engagement and the road that led to it.

Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig Announce Their Engagement

The couple confirmed their engagement on October 21. They had actually been engaged since spring 2026 and kept it quiet for several months before sharing it.

Shue spoke to People about the news. He said, "I don't know how it happened, but there's a happy ending," and added that he and Fiebig feel happy and grateful. He also described feeling "very grateful and hopeful," according to TMZ's summary of the interview.

As for plans, reports say the couple is planning their wedding. No date, venue, or guest details have been made public.

How Did Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig's Relationship Begin?

It began as a friendship. Reports say it's unclear exactly when they first met, but they moved in the same social circles while married to Robach and Holmes.

After their marriages ended, they leaned on each other. Shue told People that it was simply how they got to know each other, at a time when both needed a friend. Nothing in his account suggests a plan. It reads like two people supporting each other through a hard stretch.

Things eventually turned romantic, and their relationship was confirmed in December 2023. That was when it first became public.

Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig's Relationship Timeline

Here are the key moments, based on published reports:

2010: Fiebig marries Holmes in March. They welcome a daughter, Sabine, in 2013. Shue marries Robach the same year.
November 2022: Photos of Robach and Holmes together surface while both are still married.
December 2022: Holmes files for divorce from Fiebig.
March 2023: Robach and Shue's divorce is finalized after 13 years of marriage.
October 2023: The Holmes and Fiebig separation is finalized.
December 2023: Shue and Fiebig are first spotted in public together.
June 2024: The pair are photographed kissing in New York City, about six months after the news broke.
2025: A source tells Us Weekly they have moved in together, saying "It's not revenge. It's real."
October 2026: The engagement is confirmed.

Their relationship stayed low-key for years. That fits the reports that they kept things private to avoid media attention. If you like following celebrity love stories, another celebrity wedding story makes a good companion read.

Who Are Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig's Former Spouses?

Andrew Shue's Previous Marriage to Amy Robach

Shue and Robach married in 2010 and raised a blended family. Robach was a familiar face on ABC News, best known as a co-anchor of GMA3: What You Need to Know. Their divorce was finalized in March 2023.

Marilee Fiebig's Previous Marriage to T.J. Holmes

Fiebig and Holmes married in March 2010. Fiebig has a strong career of her own. She studied at the University of Michigan and earned her law degree at Vanderbilt, with a background in immigration law. She has been Chief Diversity Officer at Save the Children since June 2021, and was previously Chief of Staff at Roc Nation.

What Happened Between Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes?

Robach and Holmes co-hosted GMA3: What You Need to Know on ABC. In November 2022, photos of the two together became public while both were still legally married. The story exploded.

Both have said they were already separated and in the middle of divorce proceedings. But neither had publicly confirmed a split at the time. ABC took them off the air in December 2022, and both left the network in early 2023.

That scandal dragged their spouses into the spotlight, too. Shue and Fiebig went from private figures to names people searched, and their later romance only added to the curiosity. Robach and Holmes have since built a public life as a couple and podcast hosts. For a look at a very different kind of marital breakup, there is this celebrity divorce story.

What Andrew Shue Has Said About Love and Second Chances

Shue's comments to People focus on growth. He said he had to move through a lot of pain, struggle, and humility. He described the "magic" of love as the shift from needing someone to giving to them.

On family, the public record is thinner. Reports describe a newly blended family, with Shue's sons and Fiebig's daughter. Beyond that, he hasn't shared detailed thoughts on family in the available coverage, so it's best not to guess.

When it comes to finding the right partner, his own words say it best: friendship came first. Readers who like relationship wisdom may enjoy Ice-T's marriage advice.

What Is Next for Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig?

Not much is confirmed. There is no public wedding date, location, or ring detail. What is clear is that they are engaged and, according to reports, in the early stages of planning.

An earlier insider said that after being hurt before, they were cautious about marriage. That makes the timing of this announcement feel less like a rush and more like a decision made slowly, and kept private for months.

The Bottom Line

Shue and Fiebig's story is built on friendship, patience, and privacy, which is why it stands out. For anything beyond what they've shared, wait for confirmation from the couple. Bookmark this page, and we'll keep it current as new details come out.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig engaged?

Yes. They confirmed the news on October 21, 2026, and Shue said the proposal happened in spring 2026.

How long have Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig been dating?

Their relationship was confirmed in December 2023, so they have been a public couple for nearly three years.

How did Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig meet?

Exactly when they first met is unclear. They shared social circles while married to Robach and Holmes, and became close friends after those marriages ended.